How Will Patriots Replace Mike Nugent? Examining Free Agent Kicker Market

by

Oct 29, 2019

For the second time this season, the New England Patriots are in the market for a new kicker.

The Patriots reportedly put an end to the Mike Nugent experiment Tuesday, cutting the 38-year-old journeyman less than a month after signing him.

Nugent appeared in four games for New England as Stephen Gostkowski’s replacement, going 5-for-8 of field-goal attempts and 15-for-16 on extra points while never attempting a kick longer than 40 yards. The Patriots radically altered their fourth-down approach following Gostkowski’s season-ending hip injury, passing up seven field-goal tries from between 37 and 53 yards during Nugent’s brief tenure.

The Patriots, who visit the Baltimore Ravens on Sunday night, must now work quickly to find a replacement for Nugent. The most obvious candidate is 44-year-old Matt Bryant, whom the Atlanta Falcons released Tuesday.

Bryant was just 9-for-14 on field-goal attempts for Atlanta this season (64.3 percent), though four of those five misses came from 50-plus yards out. He spent the last 11 seasons kicking in a dome and has little experience with wintery weather conditions.

Since joining the Falcons in 2009, Bryant has played in sub-freezing temperatures just four times, going 2-for-5 on field goals in those games (misses from 48, 52 and 53). Still, he might be the most talented option at this point.

If Bryant doesn’t pique the Patriots’ interest, here’s a quick look some of the other currently available free agent kickers (those marked with an asterisk reportedly have worked out for the Patriots this season):

Kai Forbath*
Age: 32
Last team: Jacksonville Jaguars
2018 stats: 4-of-5 field goals (80 percent); 3-of-3 extra points (100 percent)
Career stats: 120-of-149 field goals (85.7 percent); 172-of-183 extra points (94.0 percent)

Giorgio Tavecchio*
Age: 29
Last team: Atlanta Falcons
2018 stats: 5 of 5 field goals (100 percent); 8 of 8 extra points (100 percent)
Career stats: 21 of 26 field goals (80.8 percent); 41 of 42 extra points (97.6 percent)

Blair Walsh*
Age: 29
Last team: Atlanta Falcons
2018 stats: N/A
Career stats: 154 of 187 field goals (82.4 percent); 193 of 203 extra points (95.1 percent)

Cairo Santos
Age: 27
Last team: Tennessee Titans
2019 stats: 4 of 9 field goals (44.4 percent); 12 of 12 extra points (100 percent)
Career stats: 108 of 134 field goals (80.6 percent); 161 of 167 extra points (96.4 percent)

Nick Folk*
Age: 34
Last team: Tampa Bay Buccaneers
2018 stats: N/A
Career stats: 245 of 305 field goals (80.3 percent); 342 of 346 extra points (98.8 percent)

Nick Rose*
Age: 25
Last team: Los Angeles Chargers
2018 stats: N/A
Career stats: 11 of 14 field goals (78.6 percent); 23 of 26 extra points (88.5 percent)

Greg Joseph*
Age: 25
Last team: Cleveland Browns
2018 stats: 17 of 20 field goals (85.0 percent); 25 of 29 extra points (86.2 percent)
Career stats: 17 of 20 field goals (85.0 percent); 25 of 29 extra points (86.2 percent)

Matt McCrane
Age: 25
Last team: Pittsburgh Steelers
2018 stats: 8 of 12 field goals (66.7 percent); 9 of 9 extra points (100 percent)
Career stats: 8 of 12 field goals (66.7 percent); 9 of 9 extra points (100 percent)

Kaare Vedvik
Age: 26
Last team: New York Jets
2018 stats: N/A
Career stats: 0 for 1 field goals (zero percent); 0 for 1 extra points (94.0 percent)

Matthew Wright*
Age: 23
Last team: Pittsburgh Steelers
2018 stats: N/A
Career stats: N/A

Chris Blewitt
Age: 24
Last team: Chicago Bears
2018 stats: N/A
Career stats: N/A

Elliot Fry*
Age: 24
Last team: Baltimore Ravens
2018 stats: N/A
Career stats: N/A

Austin MacGuinness*
Age: 24
Last team: Memphis Express (AAF)
2018 stats: N/A
Career stats: N/A

Sebastian Janikowski (retired)
Age: 41
Last team: Seattle Seahawks
2018 stats: 22 of 27 field goals (81.5 percent); 48 of 51 extra points (94.1 percent)
Career stats: 436 of 542 field goals (80.4 percent); 605 of 614 extra points (98.5 percent)

Thumbnail photo via Reinhold Matay/USA TODAY Sports Images
Washington Redskins offensive tackle Trent Williams
Previous Article

NFL Rumors: Tackle Trent Williams Ends Holdout, Reports To Redskins

San Jose Sharks Center Joe Thornton
Next Article

Joe Thornton Not Thinking About Potential Last Trip To Boston To Face Bruins

Picked For You