Ranking Each Of Bill Belichick’s Patriots Drafts From Best To Worst

Bill Belichick has presided over 18 NFL drafts during this time as head coach and de facto general manager of the New England Patriots. We spent our Monday morning ranking them all.

Without further ado, here are our totally subjective and highly unscientific power rankings of each Patriots draft from 2000 to 2016. (Note: It’s too early to properly judge the 2017 draft class, so that one wasn’t considered for this exercise.)

1. 2003
Picks: DT Ty Warren (first round), S Eugene Wilson (second), WR Bethel Johnson (second), DT Dan Klecko (fourth), CB Asante Samuel (fourth), C Dan Koppen (fifth), QB Kliff Kingsbury (sixth), FB Spencer Nead (seventh), LB Tully Banta-Cain (seventh), DT Ethan Kelley (seventh)

This was a tremendous haul for the Patriots. Warren, Wilson, Samuel and Koppen all started on Super Bowl-winning teams, and even Banta-Cain became a starter late in his career, recording 10 sacks for New England in 2009. Johnson never became a true offensive weapon but was dangerous as a return man.

2. 2002
Picks: TE Daniel Graham (first), WR Deion Branch (second), QB Rohan Davey (fourth), DE Jarvis Green (fourth), RB Antwoine Womack (seventh), WR David Givens (seventh)

From a hit percentage standpoint, it’s hard to beat 2002. Of these six players, only Davey and Womack failed to make a significant impact for the Patriots.

3. 2000
Picks: OG Adrian Klemm (second), RB J.R. Redmond (third), OT Greg Randall (fourth), TE Dave Stachelski (fifth), DT Jeff Marriott (fifth), DB Antwan Harris (sixth), QB Tom Brady (sixth), DE David Nugent (sixth), LB Casey Tisdale (seventh), FB Patrick Pass (seventh)

The 2000 draft largely yielded bit players and nobodies for New England, but the selection of one Thomas Edward Patrick Brady Jr. at No. 199 alone is enough to earn it a top-three spot on this list.

4. 2010
Picks: CB Devin McCourty (first), TE Rob Gronkowski (second), LB Jermaine Cunningham (second), LB Brandon Spikes (second), WR Taylor Price (third), TE Aaron Hernandez (fourth), P Zoltan Mesko (fifth), C Ted Larsen (sixth), OT Thomas Welch (seventh), DE Brandon Deaderick (seventh), DT Kade Weston (seventh), QB Zac Robinson (seventh)

Had Hernandez’s NFL career not ended when and how it did, this easily could have become Belichick’s best draft class ever. Even still, it’s right up there. It’s tough to find a better first- and second-round pairing than McCourty (who was drafted as a cornerback before moving to safety) and Gronkowski.

5. 2012
Picks: DE Chandler Jones (first), LB Dont’a Hightower (first), S Tavon Wilson (second), DE Jake Bequette (third), S Nate Ebner (sixth), CB Alfonzo Dennard (seventh), WR Jeremy Ebert (seventh)

This was one of just two times Belichick made two first-round picks, and he hit on both, with Jones and Hightower becoming superstars in the Patriots’ defense.

6. 2005
Picks: OG Logan Mankins (first), CB Ellis Hobbs (third), OT Nick Kaczur (third), S James Sanders (fourth), LB Ryan Claridge (fifth), QB Matt Cassel (seventh), TE Andy Stokes (seventh)

Mankins is a potential Hall of Famer, and Hobbs, Kaczur and Sanders all were multi-year starters for the Patriots. Cassel filled in for an injured Tom Brady in 2008 and guided New England to an 11-5 record. He’s still kicking around the league as a backup.

7. 2015
Picks: DT Malcom Brown (first), S Jordan Richards (second), DE Geneo Grissom (third), DE Trey Flowers (fourth), OG Tre’ Jackson (fourth), OG Shaq Mason (fourth), LS Joe Cardona (fifth), LB Matthew Wells (sixth), TE A.J. Derby (sixth), CB Darryl Roberts (seventh), LB Xzavier Dickson (seventh)

Richard, Grissom and Jackson were misses, but the Patriots offset those by nabbing Brown in the first and Flowers and Mason in the fourth. The latter two were particularly good value.

8. 2001
Picks: DE Richard Seymour (first), OT Matt Light (second), CB Brock Williams (third), OT Kenyatta Jones (fourth), TE Jabari Holloway (fourth), LB Hakim Akbar (fifth), TE Arthur Love (sixth), CB Leonard Myers (sixth), K Owen Pochman (seventh), LB T.J. Turner (seventh)

Sure, most of these guys were bums, but Seymour and Light were franchise cornerstones.

9. 2011
Picks: OT Nate Solder (first), CB Ras-I Dowling (second), RB Shane Vereen (second), RB Stevan Ridley (third), QB Ryan Mallett (third), OT Marcus Cannon (fifth), TE Lee Smith (fifth), LB Markell Carter (sixth), DB Malcolm Williams (seventh)

The Marcus Cannon renaissance of 2016 pushed this draft — which also featured a franchise left tackle and two productive backs — up a few spots.

10. 2004
Picks: NT Vince Wilfork (first), TE Ben Watson (first), DE Marquise Hill (second), S Guss Scott (third), S Dexter Reid (fourth), RB Cedric Cobbs (fourth), WR P.K. Sam (fifth), CB Christian Morton (seventh)

Much like in 2001, this draft had two big hits at the top and a whole lot of nothing below them.

11. 2009
Picks: S Patrick Chung (second), DT Ron Brace (second), CB Darius Butler (second), OT Sebastian Vollmer (second), WR Brandon Tate (third), LB Tyrone McKenzie (third), OG Rich Ohrnberger (fourth), OT George Bussey (fifth), C Jake Ingram (sixth), DT Myron Pryor (sixth), WR Julian Edelman (seventh), DT Darryl Richard (seventh)

The Patriots whiffed on most of their picks in 2009 but found a few gems in Chung, Vollmer and Edelman. Chung had to wait until his second stint with the team to emerge as a legitimate star.

12. 2013
Picks: LB Jamie Collins (second), WR Aaron Dobson (second), CB Logan Ryan (third), S Duron Harmon (third), WR Josh Boyce (fourth), DE Michael Buchanan (seventh), LB Steve Beauharnais (seventh)

The Patriots found three starting-caliber defenders in 2013, but Belichick’s long-standing struggle to draft quality wideouts was especially apparent here.

13. 2014
Picks: DT Dominique Easley (first), QB Jimmy Garoppolo (second), C Bryan Stork (fourth), RB James White (fourth), OT Cameron Fleming (fourth), OL Jon Halapio (sixth), DE Zach Moore (sixth), CB Jemea Thomas (seventh), WR Jeremy Gallon (seventh)

Easley might go down as the worst first-round pick of the Belichick era. The Patriots cut him less than two years after drafting him. White is the only player from this draft class who still is with the team.

14. 2008
Picks: LB Jerod Mayo (first), CB Terrence Wheatley (second), LB Shawn Crable (third), QB Kevin O’Connell (third), CB Jonathan Wilhite (fourth), WR Matthew Slater (fifth), LB Bo Ruud (sixth)

Mayo was a big hit a No. 10 overall, and Slater is one of the best special teams players in NFL history. Other than that? Yuck.

15. 2016
Picks: CB Cyrus Jones (second), OG Joe Thuney (third), QB Jacoby Brissett (third), DT Vincent Valentine (third), WR Malcolm Mitchell (fourth), LB Kamu Grugier-Hill (sixth), LB Elandon Roberts (sixth), OG Ted Karras (sixth), WR Devin Lucien (seventh)

All of these players still are early in their careers, so this draft certainly has the potential for upward movement. But so far, Thuney has been the only definitive hit. We’ll see this season whether Jones, Valentine and Mitchell can come back from injuries that cost them the entire 2017 campaign.

16. 2006
Picks: RB Laurence Maroney (first), WR Chad Jackson (second), TE David Thomas (third), FB Garrett Mills (fourth), K Stephen Gostkowski (fourth), OT Ryan O’Callaghan (fifth), DE Jeremy Mincey (sixth), OG Dan Stevenson (sixth), DT Le Kevin Smith (sixth), CB Willie Andrews (seventh)

The Patriots found an A+ replacement for Adam Vinatieri in 2006. That was about the only positive that came out of this draft.

17. 2007
Picks: S Brandon Meriweather (first), DT Kareem Brown (fourth), OT Clint Oldenburg (fifth), LB Justin Rodgers (sixth), CB Mike Richardson (sixth), RB Justise Hairston (sixth), OT Corey Hilliard (sixth), LB Oscar Lua (seventh), OG Mike Elgin (seventh)

New England owned just one of the first 126 selections in this draft, and it showed. Meriweather was the only solid pro to come out of this class.

Click here for the latest NFL mock draft >>